Jim Harvey'sManagement Ignition Open your team

User guide · The thinking behind it

Giving feedback

The method behind Feedback Ignite, from Jim Harvey's guide The Art of Managing.

The idea

Feedback has one job: to help someone see what they cannot yet see, so they can act on it.

Most managers who avoid feedback have tried it and watched it misfire. The person got defensive, or nodded and changed nothing, or the message was cushioned until it disappeared. So the behaviour carries on, and six months later it surprises everyone at the appraisal.

Feedback works when it is specific, honest, and grounded in belief that the person can improve. Take any one of the three away and it stops working.

What the person gets. An honest picture of how they are doing, and a reason to raise their game. Engaged people need inclusion, control and openness from their manager. This skill gives them openness.

The method

Four parts

  1. The observation. What you saw or heard, on a particular occasion.
  2. The impact. The effect it had on the work, the team or the client.
  3. The question. How does that match their own sense of how it went?
  4. The agreement. What each of you will do next time.

The question does most of the work. People accept feedback they have been invited to think about. It also protects you: sometimes the answer shows you did not have the full picture.

Name the behaviour

"She lacks confidence" describes a person. "She did not put her view to the client in Tuesday's meeting" describes something she can change. Feedback names the behaviour and its effect.

Style

Some people want feedback short and straight. Others want room to talk it through. Ask them which they prefer, once. It pays back in every conversation after.

Before the conversation

Give them notice the day before, and ask them to come ready with their own view. Then ask for it before you give yours. Good people are often harder on themselves than you would be.

How Feedback Ignite uses it

You write rough notes in your own words. Feedback Ignite checks they name a real occasion, and asks in square brackets for any detail that is missing. It reads your notes for the behaviour, its effect, and any strength behind it, and turns judgements about character into behaviour the person can act on.

You choose the style, Empathetic or Direct. The note for them is a short letter in three parts, with no headings:

You also get a suggested rhythm for follow-up, and a guide for the conversation pitched to their skill and confidence. The note uses only the facts you gave it.

"If you cannot describe what the person should do differently, you are not ready to give the feedback."

Jim Harvey, The Art of Managing

The other methods: Goal setting · Delegating · Coaching · Running 1-1s and team meetings